APOD: Layered Hills in Arabia Terra on Mars (2010 Aug 15)

Post a reply


This question is a means of preventing automated form submissions by spambots.
Smilies
:D :) :ssmile: :( :o :shock: :? 8-) :lol2: :x :P :oops: :cry: :evil: :roll: :wink: :!: :?: :idea: :arrow: :| :mrgreen:
View more smilies

BBCode is ON
[img] is ON
[url] is ON
Smilies are ON

Topic review
   

Expand view Topic review: APOD: Layered Hills in Arabia Terra on Mars (2010 Aug 15)

The GREAT ARTesian Basin

by neufer » Wed Aug 15, 2012 6:28 pm

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Groundwater_on_Mars wrote: <<During past ages, there was rain and/or snow on Mars; especially in the Noachian and early Hesperian epochs.

Some locations on the Red Planet show groups of layered rocks. Rock layers are present under the resistant caps of pedestal craters, on the floors of many large impact craters, and in the area called Arabia. In some places the layers are arranged into regular patterns. It has been suggested that the layers were put into place by volcanoes, the wind, or by being at the bottom of a lake or sea. Calculations and simulations show that groundwater carrying dissolved minerals would surface in the same locations that have abundant rock layers. According to these ideas, deep canyons and large craters would receive water coming from the ground. Many craters in the Arabia area of Mars contain groups of layers. Some of these layers may have resulted from climate changes. The tilt of the rotational axis of Mars has repeatedly changed in the past. Some changes are large. Because of these variations of climate, at times the atmosphere of Mars will be much thicker and contain more moisture. The amount of atmospheric dust also has also increased and decreased. It is believed that these frequent changes helped to deposit material in craters and other low places. The rising of mineral-rich ground water cemented these materials. The model also predicts that after a crater is full of layered rocks; additional layers will be laid down in the area around the crater. So, the model predicts that layers may also have formed in intercrater regions; layers in these regions have been observed. Layers can be hardened by the action of groundwater. Martian ground water probably moved hundreds of kilometers, and in the process it dissolved many minerals from the rock it passed through. When ground water surfaces in low areas containing sediments, water evaporates in the thin atmosphere and leaves behind minerals as deposits and/or cementing agents. Consequently, layers of dust could not later easily erode away since they were cemented together. On Earth, mineral-rich waters often evaporate forming large deposits of various types of salts and other minerals. Sometimes water flows through Earth’s aquifers, and then evaporates at the surface just as is hypothesed for Mars. One location this occurs on Earth is the Great Artesian Basin of Australia. On Earth the hardness of many sedimentary rocks, like sandstone, is largely due to the cement that was put in place as water passed through.

Many areas on Mars show inverted relief. In those places, former stream channels are displayed as raised beds, instead of stream valleys. Raised beds form when old stream channels become filled with material that is resistant to erosion. After later erosion removes surrounding soft materials, more resistant materials that were deposited in the stream bed are left behind. Lava is one substance that can flow down valleys and produce such inverted terrain. However, fairly loose materials can get quite hard and erosion resistant when cemented by minerals. These minerals can come from groundwater. It is thought that a low point, like a valley focuses groundflow, so more water and cements move into it, and this results in a greater degree of cementation.

Orbiting probes showed that the type of rock around Opportunity was present in a very large area that included Arabia, which is about as large as Europe. A spectroscope, called CRISM, on the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter found sulfates in many of the same places that the upwelling water model had predicted, including some areas of Arabia. The model predicted deposits in Valles Marineris canyons; these deposits have been observed and found to contain sulfates. Other locations predicted to have upwelling water, for example chaos regions and canyons associated with large outflows, have also been found to contain sulfates. Layers occur in the types of locations predicted by this model of groundwater evaporating at the surface. Layers have been observed around the site that Opportunity landed and in nearby Arabia. The ground under the cap of pedestal craters sometimes displays numerous layers. The cap of a pedestal crater protects material under it from eroding away. It is accepted that the material that now is only found under the pedestal crater’s cap formerly covered the whole region. Some craters contain mounds of layered material that reach above the crater’s rim. Gale Crater and Crommelin Crater are two craters that hold large mounds. Such tall mounds were formed, according to this model, by layers that first filled the crater, and then continued to build up around the surrounding region. Later erosion removed material around the crater, but left a mound in the crater that was higher than its rim.>>

Re: APOD: Layered Hills in Arabia Terra on Mars (2010 Aug 15

by neufer » Wed Aug 15, 2012 6:05 pm

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arabia_Terra wrote: <<Arabia Terra is a large upland region in the north of Mars. It is densely cratered and heavily eroded. This battered topography indicates great age, and Arabia Terra is presumed to be one of the oldest terrains on the planet. It covers as much as 4500 kilometers at its longest extent, centered roughly at 19.79°N 30°ECoordinates: 19.79°N 30°E with its eastern and southern regions rising 4 kilometers above the north-west. Alongside its many craters, canyons wind through the Arabia Terra, many emptying into the large Northern lowlands of the planet, which borders Arabia Terra to the north.

Arabia contains many interesting features. There are some good examples of pedestal craters in the area. A pedestal crater has its ejecta above the surrounding terrain, often forming a steep cliff. The ejecta forms a resistant layer that protects the underlying material from erosion. Mounds and buttes on the floor of some craters display many layers. The layers may have formed by volcanic processes, by wind, or by underwater deposition. Dark slope streaks have been observed in Tikhonravov Basin, a large eroded crater. The streaks appear on steep slopes and change over time. At first they are dark, then turn a lighter color, probably by the deposition of fine, light colored dust from the atmosphere. These streaks are thought to form by dust moving downslope in a way similar to snow avalanches on Earth.>>

Re: APOD: Layered Hills in Arabia Terra on Mars (2010 Aug 15

by neufer » Wed Aug 15, 2012 2:27 pm

astronut2012 wrote:
As a geologist, I find this image very intriguing. Flat lying strata comprising the Mesas shows no evidence of deformation, indicating that the deposits that formed the Mesas were laid down during a period of no tectonic activity (at least in the Arabia Terra region), with folding and faulting absent. Much the same geological conditions were prevalent when the strata of Mesas in Arizona were deposited.
Secondly, the Mesas are predominantly S – N aligned teardrop shapes in the form of giant ‘ventifacts’ carved by southerly winds, with the elongated ends of the teardrops pointing downwind and the median spines parallel to the prevailing wind direction. It is possible that the Mesas have been eroded into these shapes over time by katabatic winds blowing towards the polar ice caps due to seasonal heating of the equatorial regions causing a wide band of elevated pressure encircling the planet. Note that the younger parabolic dunes have the same S – N alignment, but the material comprising them has a different provenance, possibly extensive areas of dark Iron and Magnesium rich bedrock exposed by wind ablation in equatorial and temperate regions.
  • At 8.9º N Mars would have permanent NE trade winds.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_of_Mars#Wind wrote: <<The surface of Mars has a very low thermal inertia, which means it heats quickly when the sun shines on it. Typical daily temperature swings, away from the polar regions, are around 100 K. On Earth, winds often develop in areas where thermal inertia changes suddenly, such as from sea to land. There are no seas on Mars, but there are areas where the thermal inertia of the soil changes, leading to morning and evening winds akin to the sea breezes on Earth.

At low latitudes the Hadley circulation dominates, and is essentially the same as the process which on Earth generates the trade winds. One of the major differences between Mars' and Earth's Hadley circulations is their speed which is measured on an overturning timescale. The overturning timescale on Mars is about 100 Martian days while on Earth, it is over a year.

At higher latitudes a series of high and low pressure areas, called baroclinic pressure waves, dominate the weather. Mars is dryer and colder than Earth, and in consequence dust raised by these winds tends to remain in the atmosphere longer than on Earth as there is no precipitation to wash it out (excepting CO2 snowfall).>>

Re: APOD: Layered Hills in Arabia Terra on Mars (2010 Aug 15

by astronut2012 » Wed Aug 15, 2012 12:07 pm

As a geologist, I find this image very intriguing. Flat lying strata comprising the Mesas shows no evidence of deformation, indicating that the deposits that formed the Mesas were laid down during a period of no tectonic activity (at least in the Arabia Terra region), with folding and faulting absent. Much the same geological conditions were prevalent when the strata of Mesas in Arizona were deposited.
Secondly, the Mesas are predominantly S – N aligned teardrop shapes in the form of giant ‘ventifacts’ carved by southerly winds, with the elongated ends of the teardrops pointing downwind and the median spines parallel to the prevailing wind direction. It is possible that the Mesas have been eroded into these shapes over time by katabatic winds blowing towards the polar ice caps due to seasonal heating of the equatorial regions causing a wide band of elevated pressure encircling the planet. Note that the younger parabolic dunes have the same S – N alignment, but the material comprising them has a different provenance, possibly extensive areas of dark Iron and Magnesium rich bedrock exposed by wind ablation in equatorial and temperate regions.

I'd love to be a planetary geologist!

Re: APOD: Layered Hills in Arabia Terra on Mars (2010 Aug 15

by rstevenson » Sun Aug 22, 2010 4:53 pm

You're welcome. It's often difficult to conceptualize landforms on other planets from aerial photos. We're used to a planet that just loves to smooth things out, using water, wind and fecund greenery. Recall how it took only a few hundred years to almost make the huge "layered hills" of the Aztec and Mayan civilizations disappear in the jungles of Central and South America. The stark landforms we see on Mars often look unreal to us wet Earth people, (he said with deliberate ambiguity.)

Rob

Re: APOD: Layered Hills in Arabia Terra on Mars (2010 Aug 15

by Ann » Sun Aug 22, 2010 3:52 pm

rstevenson wrote:Here's a 3D image of part of Arabia Terra, as referenced on this page, about 1/3 of the way down.
081204-rock-layers-02.jpg
Rob
Rob, I forgot to tell you. Thanks for posting this image! It clarifies a lot. I'm still in awe of these striated hills, though!

Ann

Re: APOD: Layered Hills in Arabia Terra on Mars (2010 Aug 15

by desparate » Sun Aug 22, 2010 3:42 pm

Could this be an area of superheated mud in the past?
Superheated mud would spurt out periodically forming circular patterns overtime and building hills or mounds. The lower smooth areas could have been where water settled out after mud and steam gushed after an eruption...

Re: APOD: Layered Hills in Arabia Terra on Mars (2010 Aug 15

by Chappy » Tue Aug 17, 2010 8:18 pm

What a fascinating image!
The detail is spectacular, and I disagree with some other posters...the contrast in this image is far superior to what a color image would show.

@Peter Eckhoff - Do you mean this one?

Image

Uploaded with ImageShack.us

I don't think this is a boulder from this mound, although it's very probable that many pieces do break away and roll down at times.
Similar striations can be seen on other mounds as well, with no associated boulder visible. I don't even think such a boulder would even be visible at this resolution, I think what you see as a boulder is actually a small mound itself. Looking at it really closely also revealed (to me) that what appears to be a single striation from a possible boulder rolling down, is more likely 2 separate ones.
There are also other similar small mounds scattered around that look exactly like this one, that aren't close to larger mounds that they may have broken away from, so this leads me to believe that it's just a separate small mound itself, that just kinda lines up with the striations in the big mound.

Re: APOD: Layered Hills in Arabia Terra on Mars (2010 Aug 15

by B » Mon Aug 16, 2010 7:15 am

would it be possible to generate a 3D computer image of the region?? an artist could then work out scenes of the topography as human eyes would see it..

Re: APOD: Layered Hills in Arabia Terra on Mars (2010 Aug 15

by JR in WV » Sun Aug 15, 2010 8:33 pm

I'm with the Strip Mining post! Bolt Mountain in SW WV looked just like this until the trees began to grow on the flat benches.

So now we know that the Martians didn't care for their environment any better than we are, with the result that their planet became uninhabitable! Curses, they're ahead of us again!!

;-)

Wonderful images, all! Thanks!

Re: APOD: Layered Hills in Arabia Terra on Mars (2010 Aug 15

by keshlam » Sun Aug 15, 2010 8:04 pm

Actually, there's a simple initial test: Do all the hills in the same area have steps at about the same heights (allowing, if necessary, for some possible distortion by uneven uplift)? Or, if they're uneven, is the bias minor and consistently in a particular direction? Either would tend to confirm the progressively-receding-shoreline idea, since one would expect liquid to seek roughly the same height across an area (modulo local masscons and persistent currents).

If the heights, and heights of the steps, are irregular that would tend to argue against this theory.


I think there's consensus that Mars did once have significant amounts surface water, right?

Re: APOD: Layered Hills in Arabia Terra on Mars (2010 Aug 15

by keshlam » Sun Aug 15, 2010 7:43 pm

I tend to agree that what I'd suspect if I saw this on earth -- ignoring human activity -- is sedimentary layers being eroded away by slowly receding water, perhaps with harder and softer layers alternating (which tends to result in undercutting and collapse, thus leaving relatively sharp-edged plateaus). If the water is going down at a relatively steady rate, that could account for the thresholds being fairly evenly spaced, as they fall below the threshold for each new undermining sequence...

Yeah, I'm stretching a bit. But given some of the "impossibly" flat-topped and steep-sided structures on Earth which were created by a weather-resistant capstone over softer rock... and given that Earth has had periods where inland seas either gradually receded or broke free and drained away...

I have to admit that it does look a lot like terracing or mountaintop-removal, though your mention of "wide enough to drive a truck around" may be biasing that perception.

Re: APOD: Layered Hills in Arabia Terra on Mars (2010 Aug 15

by Beyond » Sun Aug 15, 2010 6:17 pm

To me, it is quite evident that water flowed through there at some time in the past.

Also - if you frost a two layer cake, you still have a two layer cake.
Frosting neufer's 12 layer cake all of a sudden turns it into a 24 layer cake. No wonder no-one understands the new math :!:

Re: APOD: Layered Hills in Arabia Terra on Mars (2010 Aug 15

by rstevenson » Sun Aug 15, 2010 5:15 pm

thearborist wrote:Since these are formed in what is apparently sedimentary rock layers, could they be sink holes? Put a layer of sand on a cardboard, then punch a hole it it. The effect looks about the same, especially if the sand is compacted in layers. Maybe a bubble formed the hills and left a void below that later collapsed. Or to carry it to the bizzare/extreme, may it was giant Martian ‘ants’ whose nest collapsed.
I think you may be picturing these inside out. They're hills, not pits. Aerial photos (or orbital, in this case) can be tricky to properly orient yourself as to in/out, but these are definitely outies, not innies.

Rob

Re: APOD: Layered Hills in Arabia Terra on Mars (2010 Aug 15

by thearborist » Sun Aug 15, 2010 5:07 pm

Since these are formed in what is apparently sedimentary rock layers, could they be sink holes? Put a layer of sand on a cardboard, then punch a hole it it. The effect looks about the same, especially if the sand is compacted in layers. Maybe a bubble formed the hills and left a void below that later collapsed. Or to carry it to the bizzare/extreme, may it was giant Martian ‘ants’ whose nest collapsed.

Re: APOD: Layered Hills in Arabia Terra on Mars (2010 Aug 15

by rstevenson » Sun Aug 15, 2010 5:04 pm

Here's a 3D image of part of Arabia Terra, as referenced on this page, about 1/3 of the way down.
081204-rock-layers-02.jpg
Rob

Re: APOD: Layered Hills in Arabia Terra on Mars (2010 Aug 15

by Ann » Sun Aug 15, 2010 4:53 pm

FrogSplash wrote:I wonder what these would look like in color. Come on NASA color photography isn't that expensive. Not false color either I want the real thing.
Hmmm, I'm glad that someone sees it my way! :wink:

Color or no color, some of those layered hills look just eerily perfect.

Ann

Re: APOD: Layered Hills in Arabia Terra on Mars (2010 Aug 15

by Peter Eckhoff » Sun Aug 15, 2010 4:06 pm

Did anyone notice the boulder that rolled down one of the terraces? It started near the top of the terrace and rolled in the 300 degree direction and now rest slightly away from the terrace just offshore in one of the "lakes". Might be of interest to a geologist investigating the geology of the terraces and "lakes".

Re: APOD: Layered Hills in Arabia Terra on Mars (2010 Aug 15

by owlice » Sun Aug 15, 2010 3:49 pm

Darn you, neufer! Now I want a 24-layer Chocolate Cake for my next birthday cake; yellow cake with chocolate frosting just might not cut it next time!

(But since I'm old and have a pea-brain, I will not remember this by the time my birthday rolls around, so yellow cake with chocolate frosting will work just fine!)

Re: APOD: Layered Hills in Arabia Terra on Mars (2010 Aug 15

by Chris Peterson » Sun Aug 15, 2010 3:10 pm

FrogSplash wrote:I wonder what these would look like in color. Come on NASA color photography isn't that expensive. Not false color either I want the real thing.
You are mistaken. Color photography can be very expensive. A color camera might be of very little scientific value, and would displace an instrument capable of producing useful data. High quality imaging involves taking multiple images through different filters. This allows details about composition to be worked out. When a camera is stationary, or moving slowly with respect to its target, multiple images through different filters can be combined to reproduce color. But when everything is moving, as here with a low orbit camera, combining images becomes difficult. This image was made with very specific science goals in mind, and producing a color image to please the crowds was apparently not one of them.

This is an old image. The newer MRO probe has the HiRISE camera. It is, in fact, a sort of color camera, although the three bands are not intended to provide true color. However, the data can be transformed to provide a reasonable approximation of color as we would see it. But again, that isn't the primary goal.

False color images are generally much more useful.

Re: APOD: Layered Hills in Arabia Terra on Mars (2010 Aug 15

by Raum » Sun Aug 15, 2010 2:46 pm

They look like the result of a very strong or long-period erosion cycle generated by a prevailing wind or current. Most of the hills are now teardrop or pointed to the upper right of the photo. It would be fascinating to determine how long each period was and how long ago they stopped. The weather that did this must have stopped or the hills would be completely gone. The most aerodynamic hills on the right show the most layers because the tops did not wear away as fast as the more blunt hills. This may point to more than just weather patterns on Mars.

Re: APOD: Layered Hills in Arabia Terra on Mars (2010 Aug 15

by León » Sun Aug 15, 2010 2:02 pm

The mention of the trucks is related to open pit mines, like the image below
Image
But they are (transcribe) Eastern Arabia Terra is mantled in a layer of dust a few centimeters to a meter thick, yet contains morphologic features that suggest a history of multiple events of deposition and consolidation of fine-grained material and a significant amount of erosion. Early in Martian history, this region was affected by volcanic and fluvial activity but has since been dominated by aeolian processes. Five craters in this region contain interior mound material that ranges in height from 1600 to 2100 m above the crater floor. The fluted erosional pattern and the thermal inertia are suggestive of a weakly indurated material, and the extensive layering implies that these mounds were formed by a repeated process or processes. Although these materials primarily occur within craters, there are materials outside craters that have similar erosional features and fine laminations, suggesting a more extensive deposit. The most likely process to form this material is the deposition and cementation of air fall dust and is potentially related to Martian obliquity changes. The significant amount of erosion of the intracrater mounds unit indicates a dramatic change from a depositional environment to an erosional regime over the past 106-108 years. Currently dust is accumulating in this region in years with planet-encircling dust events, but global circulation model results indicate that dust devils may be removing slight amounts of dust from Arabia Terra. These observations suggest that the thickness of the dust mantle may not be currently increasing and may instead be in equilibrium. http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2008JGRE..11312001F
Image
Layers in crater found within the Schiaparelli crater basin as seen by Mars Global Surveyor

Re: APOD: Layered Hills in Arabia Terra on Mars (2010 Aug 15

by Case » Sun Aug 15, 2010 1:24 pm

Martians ate rice perhaps?
Image

Re: APOD: Layered Hills in Arabia Terra on Mars (2010 Aug 15

by neufer » Sun Aug 15, 2010 1:14 pm

Image
http://www.sheknows.com/articles/802151/strip-house-layer-chocolate-cake wrote:
<<Strip House, located inside Planet Hollywood Resort & Casino in Las Vegas, offers one of the most delicious chocolate cakes in the country. The famed Strip House 24-layer Chocolate Cake stands at 8 inches with 12 layers of lush chocolate cake filled with 11 layers of smooth chocolate filling and the 24th, a layer of semi-sweet ganache made of imported French chocolate. When dining at Strip House, the meal is not over until you have a slice of this decadent dessert, created by Executive Chef John Schenk. Guests can't get enough of the Strip House 24-layer Chocolate Cake. Therefore, now you can order it and have it delivered to your home. The Strip House 24-layer Chocolate Cake, which serves 8 to 10 people, can be ordered exclusively through Neiman Marcus. The cost of the cake is $95.00, plus delivery and processing is another $17.00.>>
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ganache wrote:
<<Ganache (from the French word for "jowl") is a glaze, icing, or filling for pastries made from chocolate and cream. Its origins date to around 1850, when it may have been invented in Switzerland or in France. Ganache is normally made by heating heavy/double cream, then pouring it over chopped dark semi-sweet chocolate. The mixture is stirred or blended until smooth, with liqueurs or extracts added if desired.>>

Re: APOD: Layered Hills in Arabia Terra on Mars (2010 Aug 15

by StarstruckKid » Sun Aug 15, 2010 12:12 pm

Some of these images are just too cool to be real. 8-)

Erosion of multiple sedimentary layers? Gigantic Busby Berkely dance number set with thousands of (yes) dancing Martians arranged around each ring, doing 8-legged high kicks? Martian rice farms? Planetary zits?

I'd guess the eery perfection of the terraces is evidence of no rain in a very long time.

Top