APOD: A Venus Transit Music Video from SDO (2012 Jun 11)

Post a reply


This question is a means of preventing automated form submissions by spambots.
Smilies
:D :) :ssmile: :( :o :shock: :? 8-) :lol2: :x :P :oops: :cry: :evil: :roll: :wink: :!: :?: :idea: :arrow: :| :mrgreen:
View more smilies

BBCode is ON
[img] is ON
[url] is ON
Smilies are ON

Topic review
   

Expand view Topic review: APOD: A Venus Transit Music Video from SDO (2012 Jun 11)

Re: APOD: A Venus Transit Music Video from SDO (2012 Jun 11)

by JohnD » Sat Jun 16, 2012 10:43 am

Steve,
While the mass of Venus undoubtedly can "warp spacetime" the effect will be far too small to distort the image of the Sun.
What you may be thinking of is the first demonstration in 1919 of General Relativity's ability to 'bend light', when Eddington used the solar eclipse of that year to measure the effect of the Sun's mass on light from a more distant star. See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tests_of_g ... by_the_Sun

Einstein's Lens is another way to describe gravitational lensing, seen when a whole galaxy distorts light from a source beyond to show images of the object that we could not otherwise see. You see (!): http://phys.org/news66492748.html

I say that Venus' mass can warp spacetime. Although we have no proof of that, the Gravity Probe B project has shown, by orbiting a probe around the Earth, that this is true for that planet's mass . But that was at the limit of currnent technology, and required the measurement of very small changes indeed, far less than the light beam distortion that would replicate the effetcs seen on the transit video. See: http://einstein.stanford.edu/

Hope that's of interest - or even helpful!
John

Re: APOD: A Venus Transit Music Video from SDO (2012 Jun 11)

by owlice » Sat Jun 16, 2012 9:07 am

Steve AKA Eye wrote:The distortions you folks are seeing (trabsparency) is an abeeration caused by,now get this,Einstien's Lense.
That is incorrect. What appears to be transparency is an effect of the instruments used to capture the image. See here and here for more information.

Re: APOD: A Venus Transit Music Video from SDO (2012 Jun 11)

by Steve AKA Eye » Sat Jun 16, 2012 8:45 am

The distortions you folks are seeing (trabsparency) is an abeeration caused by,now get this,Einstien's Lense. The gravity of Venus is warping spacetime around the planet and thereby bending the light passing near enough. Some of that light comes at your left eye and some at your right from opposing sides of the planet so your brain interprets it as semi transparent .Look closely at that video once more.In the shots where the sun is highly detailed behind Venus,there is a distinct pucker around the whole disc.You will see it distort the sun's features in the bacground as it moves.They twist and warp around it. It's a way cool effect and also a handy way to exactly determin the mass of the planet.
Neeto huh.

Re: APOD: A Venus Transit Music Video from SDO (2012 Jun 11)

by geckzilla » Wed Jun 13, 2012 9:45 pm

Well, that would explain why it sounded almost nothing like Requiem. I've heard remixed classical music and compared it to the original and not been able to find any similarities even though others could. Figured it was a shortcoming on my behalf rather than a misattribution.

Re: APOD: A Venus Transit Music Video from SDO (2012 Jun 11)

by RJN » Wed Jun 13, 2012 3:13 pm

I mis-attributed the music on this video. The producer of the video, Scott Wiessinger from SDO (NASA GSFC), emailed APOD to say that the correct attribution is "Dramatic Intro", a piece he found on stockmusic.net. The APOD has now been corrected, and I apologize for the mistake.
- RJN

Re: APOD: A Venus Transit Music Video from SDO (2012 Jun 11)

by owlice » Wed Jun 13, 2012 1:50 pm

Re: APOD for 6/11/2012

by bystander » Wed Jun 13, 2012 1:05 am

APOD for 6/11/2012

by Jetmo » Wed Jun 13, 2012 12:20 am

In the APOD for 6/11/2012 there is a video of the TOV in different wave lengths of light and it appears as though Venus is somewhat translucent. This is evident especially when it crosses over the edge of the sun you can plainly see the effect in the majority of the segments. This has stirred great debate amongst members of our Astronomy club. Everything from the whole event being a hoax orchestrated by NASA to solicit funding, to a photographic artifact, to something called an "after-image" caused by trapping of charge deep in the bulk substrate of the semiconductor, beyond the well of the pixel charges are not transferred out by the normal readout mechanism ("flushing"), but slowly diffuse to the surface where they produce ghost images from prior bright images. So I was wondering if anyone on this forum, or ideally someone from NASA/SDO could explain it.

Anxiously awaiting response, Vince Lannutti
Delaware Vally Amateur Astronomers

Re: APOD: A Venus Transit Music Video from SDO (2012 Jun 11)

by Laurraine » Tue Jun 12, 2012 3:19 am

The music should have been John Philip Sousa's TRANSIT OF VENUS. I think it would have been more appropriate.

Re: APOD: A Venus Transit Music Video from SDO (2012 Jun 11)

by neptunium » Tue Jun 12, 2012 3:03 am

What a striking video! Those prominences looked reallyh cool under the different colors.

Re: APOD: A Venus Transit Music Video from SDO (2012 Jun 11)

by saturno2 » Mon Jun 11, 2012 10:54 pm

The Venus transit is one phenomeno very interesting.
The astronomers can to study the atmosphere of Venus
There are elements for to see beeter the exo-planets in others " Solar systems"

Re: APOD: A Venus Transit Music Video from SDO (2012 Jun 11)

by JohnD » Mon Jun 11, 2012 10:32 pm

Among the swooning, I'm glad to see just a few technical queries, especially that on the apparrent transparancy of Venus!

In the past, I've read that one problem of observing a transit was in determining the actual moment when Venus' disk was seen entirely within the Sun's. The two edges blurred, rather like the Vase effect seen at a terrestrial sunset. There seemed to be no sign of this in the video - was it an artefact of observation through the Earth's atmosphere, or else with a mere eye rather than a precison electronic instrument?

John

Re: APOD: A Venus Transit Music Video from SDO (2012 Jun 11)

by Msp » Mon Jun 11, 2012 10:06 pm

Beautiful music and video! Watched it over and over today! Brings back the childlike wonder of looking at the stars and sky! Thank you for this experience.

Re: APOD: A Venus Transit Music Video from SDO (2012 Jun 11)

by ta152h0 » Mon Jun 11, 2012 7:24 pm

Did the intensity of the sun actually diminish slightly , measurably, to actually come to the conclusion there was an occultaion ?

Re: APOD: A Venus Transit Music Video from SDO (2012 Jun 11)

by Anthony Barreiro » Mon Jun 11, 2012 6:29 pm

Mr_Ed wrote:Just curious why in almost every transit sequence, the smooth motion of Venus frequently stops for a short time then jumps ahead - it appears jerky. Is it my computer's playback, or does everyone see it?
Ed, my guess is that the jerkiness is caused by the fact that these are edited time-lapse videos.

The whole transit took over six hours. I watched the whole thing through my little 70 mm refractor with a white light filter by the beach in Ko'olina, Oahu, Hawaii. It was a very exciting and moving experience, but in real time it would be much too long for a youtube video.

This SDO video is really beautiful. I love the ultraviolet images that show Venus against the Sun's corona, before and after she crossed the photosphere, the face of the Sun that's visible in white light.

Re: APOD: A Venus Transit Music Video from SDO (2012 Jun 11)

by LocalColor » Mon Jun 11, 2012 5:55 pm

Stunning! Watched it over and over.

Re: APOD: A Venus Transit Music Video from SDO (2012 Jun 11)

by Mr_Ed » Mon Jun 11, 2012 3:51 pm

Just curious why in almost every transit sequence, the smooth motion of Venus frequently stops for a short time then jumps ahead - it appears jerky. Is it my computer's playback, or does everyone see it?

Re: APOD: A Venus Transit Music Video from SDO (2012 Jun 11)

by bobhayner » Mon Jun 11, 2012 1:46 pm

Why can't they be forwarded?

Re: APOD: A Venus Transit Music Video from SDO (2012 Jun 11)

by Keyman » Mon Jun 11, 2012 1:44 pm

Chris, Owlice, bystander...
Thanks.

I did have the visual experience JDC did. Wondered if it was a 'defect' in the mechanism, the transmission, the display...or possibly one of those persistence of vision things in human eyes.

I knew it wasn't a fake. You guys, or NASA, or Goddard would have done a much better job covering up, if it was. *L* :lol2:

Re: APOD: A Venus Transit Music Video from SDO (2012 Jun 11)

by bystander » Mon Jun 11, 2012 1:12 pm

JDC wrote:How can your video be real? How can your supposed "disk of Venus" cross over the limb of the Sun, and we can see that limb, as well as surface features on the Sun itself, UNDER/BEHIND the disk! Unless Venus has suddenly become transparent, I think you're video is a falsehood!
Chris Peterson wrote:
owlice wrote:From what I have read, this "transparency" may be a result of detector persistence; because the AIA detectors were continually awash in light from the sun, the detectors retained the previous image (similar, I think, to the old "ghosting" one might have seen on an old television immediately after it was turned off, or burn-in on an old computer monitor) of the surface of the sun as Venus eclipsed the disk. Detectors are refreshed when looking at blank sky or dark areas. It may be that some detectors are more sensitive or prone to this persistence, which may account for this showing up more in some tracks than in others.
What you are talking about is called residual bulk image, and it occurs in CCD detectors because some electrons (which are produced when photons are captured) are trapped in the bulk structure of the silicon, below the actual pixel layer. It can be a challenge to deal with in some cases. It's certainly an issue with almost all the cameras used professionally, both on the ground and in space. It is certainly a likely candidate for this ghosting.
If anyone has another explanation for this, please share; thanks!
I've seen some comments from the camera operators that this effect might be caused by some sort of readout crosstalk between the different camera channels. The image is apparently placed simultaneously on four different detector quadrants, through different filters.

Re: APOD: A Venus Transit Music Video from SDO (2012 Jun 11)

by JDC » Mon Jun 11, 2012 12:42 pm

How can your video be real? How can your supposed "disk of Venus" cross over the limb of the Sun, and we can see that limb, as well as surface features on the Sun itself, UNDER/BEHIND the disk! Unless Venus has suddenly become transparent, I think you're video is a falsehood!

Re: APOD: A Venus Transit Music Video from SDO (2012 Jun 11)

by deathfleer » Mon Jun 11, 2012 12:33 pm

I dont care about the muzic. The sun seems to be frightenly hot, and the venus is speeding pretty fast

Re: APOD: A Venus Transit Music Video from SDO (2012 Jun 11)

by geckzilla » Mon Jun 11, 2012 12:22 pm

This music sounds almost nothing like Requiem for a Dream, which is a damn good thing, because I've heard the cringe-worthy poppy or techno beat remixes about a million times on various videos. Even remixed this far from the original, it could still make watching grass grow seem dramatic. Clint is one of my favorite composers, hands down. I wonder if he did this piece, too? It's not exactly clear to me whether he's being credited for this exact song or just Requiem for a Dream music in general.

Re: APOD: A Venus Transit Music Video from SDO (2012 Jun 11)

by orin stepanek » Mon Jun 11, 2012 11:47 am

OMG! :shock: Did you notice those Happy People Dancing again!! 8-) :D Well the music APOD today was great! I really enjoyed it! :wink:

Re: APOD: A Venus Transit Music Video from SDO (2012 Jun 11)

by bactame » Mon Jun 11, 2012 11:10 am

Really a beautifully done APOD with all the tools being used to examine her atmosphere on display as well. Where the hell is Matt is pretty good too, with lots of evidence in it about the various cultures and places in this world. But just maybe this APOD is better, even though my son's name is Matt.

Top