APOD: Saturns Hexagon and Rings (2013 Feb 20)

Post a reply


This question is a means of preventing automated form submissions by spambots.
Smilies
:D :) :ssmile: :( :o :shock: :? 8-) :lol2: :x :P :oops: :cry: :evil: :roll: :wink: :!: :?: :idea: :arrow: :| :mrgreen:
View more smilies

BBCode is ON
[img] is ON
[url] is ON
Smilies are ON

Topic review
   

Expand view Topic review: APOD: Saturns Hexagon and Rings (2013 Feb 20)

Re: APOD: Saturns Hexagon and Rings (2013 Feb 20)

by jensenq » Mon Feb 25, 2013 11:56 pm

Maybe it's not so much a hexagon, as it is a near sinusoidal wave mapped onto near the top of a sphere. In that case, could it just be resonance? What does it look like mapped to a cylinder and then amplified a bit?

Re: APOD: Saturns Hexagon and Rings (2013 Feb 20)

by Rmcdowell70 » Fri Feb 22, 2013 7:35 pm

Found this article on the yahoo science page....any connection?

http://news.yahoo.com/bizarre-star-shap ... 55730.html

Re: APOD: Saturns Hexagon and Rings (2013 Feb 20)

by ta152h0 » Wed Feb 20, 2013 11:44 pm

I wonder if this structure, gigantic as it is, is related to sound waves, like water on a speaker at some specific frequency ?

Re: APOD: Saturns Hexagon and Rings (2013 Feb 20)

by neufer » Wed Feb 20, 2013 11:33 pm

Image
Ron-Astro Pharmacist wrote:
It would be interesting if it reflected some structure underneath.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hexagon_%28disambiguation%29 wrote:
The Hexagon (l' Hexagone) is an epithet of France, owing to the shape of its European mainland. A regular hexagon is depicted on France's one- and two-euro coins

The Hexagon is the name of the national military headquarters in Batman (TV series); compare with The Pentagon

Re: APOD: Saturns Hexagon and Rings (2013 Feb 20)

by neufer » Wed Feb 20, 2013 11:23 pm

Doug Stern wrote:
In the last year or three, CBC [Canadian radio] radio program Quirks and Quarks interviewed professor at Dalhousie University studying fluid dynamics, and he related how as one speeds up a liquid vortex, one gets a progression of shapes from triangle, square, pentagon, hexagon, etc as the vortex is speeded up. I contacted the professor re the hexagonal pattern on Saturn and he thought it could be explained by this process.
http://asterisk.apod.com/viewtopic.php?f=29&t=30276&p=188834#p188826 wrote:
<<The population of Flatland can "evolve" through the "Law of Nature", which states: "a male child shall have one more side than his father, so that each generation shall rise (as a rule) one step in the scale of development and nobility. Thus the son of a Triangle is a Square, the son of a Square is a Pentagon, the son of a Pentagon, a Hexagon; and so on.">>
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dalhousie_University wrote:
Image
<<Dalhousie University (commonly known as Dalhousie or Dal) is a public research university with three campuses in Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada, and a fourth, the Dalhousie Agricultural Campus, in Bible Hill, Nova Scotia. It is one of Canada's oldest universities, founded during British colonial rule.

The current motto used by the university is Ora et Labora. The Latin motto is literally translated as "pray and work" and has been in use since 1870. The university had adopted the motto from the Earl of Dalhousie in order to replace the university's original motto, as the original motto was viewed by the university administration to not convey confidence. The original motto of the university was "Forsan". This Latin motto is literally translated as Perhaps and first appeared in the first Dalhousie Gazette of 1869. It was chosen from Virgil's epic poem Aeneid, Book 1, line 203, Forsan et haec olim meminisse iuvabit. The Latin motto is literally translated as "Perhaps the time may come when these difficulties will be sweet to remember".

A number of songs are commonly played and sung at various events such as commencement, convocation, and athletic contests, including the Carmina Dalhousiana.>>

Re: APOD: Saturns Hexagon and Rings (2013 Feb 20)

by Doug Stern » Wed Feb 20, 2013 10:26 pm

Hexagonal pattern probably linked to the speed of the winds at Saturn's pole.
In the last year or three, CBC [Canadian radio] radio program Quirks and Quarks interviewed professor at Dalhousie University studying fluid dynamics, and he related how as one speeds up a liquid vortex, one gets a progression of shapes from triangle, square, pentagon, hexagon, etc as the vortex is speeded up. I contacted the professor re the hexagonal pattern on Saturn and he thought it could be explained by this process.

Re: APOD: Saturns Hexagon and Rings (2013 Feb 20)

by Ron-Astro Pharmacist » Wed Feb 20, 2013 8:59 pm

Anyone know if surface elevation measurements are possible? I suppose measuring the tops of gas clouds might be difficult. Surely if we could it would tells us a lot.

Re: APOD: Saturns Hexagon and Rings (2013 Feb 20)

by msgiz » Wed Feb 20, 2013 8:47 pm

I, too, saw the documentary with the hexagonal patterns in the weather around Antarctica and was going to make the same comments as the previous commenter!

Re: APOD: Saturns Hexagon and Rings (2013 Feb 20)

by Ron-Astro Pharmacist » Wed Feb 20, 2013 7:36 pm

It would be interesting if it reflected some structure underneath.

Re: APOD: Saturns Hexagon and Rings (2013 Feb 20)

by Ron-Astro Pharmacist » Wed Feb 20, 2013 6:58 pm

Cool! Very complex structure. Swirls and eddies. To me it looks like a giant drain. Wonder if there isn't massive convection going on? It's got to be a lot colder up there. :wink:

Re: APOD: Saturns Hexagon and Rings (2013 Feb 20)

by SebastienP » Wed Feb 20, 2013 6:14 pm

Hi, there is this picture to see its compared size to that of the Earth:
Image

Re: APOD: Saturns Hexagon and Rings (2013 Feb 20)

by JoeyZola » Wed Feb 20, 2013 6:13 pm

:?: :?: Here's a curve-ball for everyone involved... Recently on a TV programme about global weather they ran a three-year sequence of Antarctica and surroundings. During the sequence, several times a perfect hexagon appeared in the wind-patterns over the continent, around the South Pole. I'd love to see someone with the resources research this and see how often that formation occurs, and perhaps in which seasons. Studying another planet's weather systems allows us to learn about our own. In this case a large planet with a large semi-permanent weather system has show us what happens on a smaller, briefer scale on our own Planet. :?: :?:

Re: APOD: Saturns Hexagon and Rings (2013 Feb 20)

by neufer » Wed Feb 20, 2013 5:32 pm

Click to play embedded YouTube video.
Chris Peterson wrote:
delgado wrote:
In this case, jovian should not be with capital, "Jovian", as it is, but rather as "jovian" , since it is not a proper name but an adjectiv.
In English, it is usual, although not universal, to retain the capital for adjectives derived from proper nouns. The several dictionaries I checked all list "Jovian" only as a capitalized adjective. That said, however, I think this is largely about style, and not any absolute rules. I'd consider either usage equally acceptable. In my own usage, I'd probably be inclined to use "jovian" in reference to the class of jovian planets, and "Jovian" when referring to Jovian winds [on Jupiter].

Re: APOD: Saturns Hexagon and Rings (2013 Feb 20)

by Chris Peterson » Wed Feb 20, 2013 5:28 pm

delgado wrote:In this case, jovian should not be with capital, "Jovian", as it is, but rather as "jovian" , since it is not a proper name but an adjectiv.
In English, it is usual, although not universal, to retain the capital for adjectives derived from proper nouns. The several dictionaries I checked all list "Jovian" only as a capitalized adjective. That said, however, I think this is largely about style, and not any absolute rules. I'd consider either usage equally acceptable.

In my own usage, I'd probably be inclined to use "jovian" in reference to the class of jovian planets, and "Jovian" when referring to Jovian winds [on Jupiter].

Re: APOD: Saturns Hexagon and Rings (2013 Feb 20)

by Chris Peterson » Wed Feb 20, 2013 5:23 pm

delgado wrote:I have seen this beautiful image of the Saturn hexagon. In the explanation it is said that the jovian plane eclipses the Saturn rings. I think his a mistake: jovian planet is Jupiter, isn't it? Can 'jovian' be used also for Saturn? Thanks
"Jovian" can refer specifically to Jupiter, or to the class of planets of which Jupiter is the exemplar. In the same way, "terrestrial" can refer specifically to Earth (Terra), or to the class of rocky planets for which Earth is the exemplar.

Re: APOD: Saturns Hexagon and Rings (2013 Feb 20)

by RJN » Wed Feb 20, 2013 5:19 pm

walfy wrote:I'm surprised the APOD writers didn't even know that very excellent science was done in trying to figure out this strange structure. Here's your answer: http://www.planetary.org/blogs/emily-la ... /2471.html
Yes that's a good link and discussion that I did indeed miss. Thanks for pointing it out! I have now linked to it under "six well defined sides".
- RJN

Re: APOD: Saturns Hexagon and Rings (2013 Feb 20)

by ta152h0 » Wed Feb 20, 2013 5:16 pm

Bucky balls. I remember now

Re: APOD: Saturns Hexagon and Rings (2013 Feb 20)

by delgado » Wed Feb 20, 2013 5:07 pm

MargaritaMc wrote:
delgado wrote:I have seen this beautiful image of the Saturn hexagon. In the explanation it is said that the jovian plane eclipses the Saturn rings. I think his a mistake: jovian planet is Jupiter, isn't it? Can 'jovian' be used also for Saturn? Thanks
The quick answer is, "Yes."

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gas_giant
A gas giant (sometimes also known as a jovian planet after the planet Jupiter, or giant planet) is a large planet that is not primarily composed of rock or other solid matter.
Margarita
Thanks!. I did not know. In this case, jovian should not be with capital, "Jovian", as it is, but rather as "jovian" , since it is not a proper name but an adjectiv. Thanks again!

Hexefoos

by neufer » Wed Feb 20, 2013 4:29 pm

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hex_sign wrote: <<Hex signs are a form of Pennsylvania Dutch folk art, related to fraktur, found in the Fancy Dutch tradition in Pennsylvania Dutch Country. Barn paintings, usually in the form of "octagon or hexagon stars in circles," grew out of the fraktur and folk art traditions about 1850 when barns first started to be painted in the area. Prior to the 1830s, the cost of paint meant that most barns were unpainted. The geometric patterns of quilts can be seen in the patterns of many hex signs.

The term hex with occult connotations may derive from the Pennsylvanian German word "hex" (German "Hexe", Dutch "Heks"), meaning "witch." However the term "hex sign" was not used until the 20th Century, after 1924 when Wallace Nutting's book Pennsylvania Beautiful was published. Before this time many Pennsylvania German farmers simply called the signs "blumme" or "schtanne" (meaning flowers or stars). However one farmer used the term "Hexefoos" in his description.

Some view the designs as decorative symbols of ethnic identification, possibly originating in reaction to 19th century attempts made by the government to suppress the Pennsylvania German language. Anabaptist sects (like the Amish and Mennonites) in the region have a negative view of hex signs. It is not surprising that hex signs are rarely, and perhaps never, seen on an Amish or Mennonite household or farm.>>

RO(ss)B(y) waves

by neufer » Wed Feb 20, 2013 3:55 pm

Chris Peterson wrote:
rstevenson wrote:
Just a few days ago I watched a recent episode of PBS's excellent Nova program, Earth From Space. Part way through it, in a section about weather systems around Antarctica, they showed a time-lapse video of low-pressure systems whirling around the continent over the space of months. A sometimes hexagonal pattern appeared in a kind of pulsating way, not always there, not always hexagonal, but definitely a pattern. It seems complex systems, given the right conditions, naturally create geometric shapes, if not always stable ones.
It is worth noting that outside of carefully contrived setups, no complex system (which, in fact, includes systems that might seem incredibly simple to us) are stable. It's always a question of how long some sort of metastability can be maintained.
I never meet a stable I didn't like.
Atmospheric RO(ss)B(y) waves were "discovered" by a Swedish American to help explain why Nova Scotia is colder than Sweden:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rossby_Waves wrote:
[img3="Meanders of the northern hemisphere's jet stream developing (a, b) and finally detaching a "drop" of cold air (c). Orange: warmer masses of air; white: jet stream. [If the Earth rotated in just
10.6 hours the polygonal pattern would be MUCH more stable]
"]http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/c ... aves_N.gif[/img3]
<<Atmospheric Rossby waves are giant meanders in high-altitude winds that are a major influence on weather.

Atmospheric Rossby waves emerge due to shear in rotating fluids, so that the Coriolis force changes along the sheared coordinate. In planetary atmospheres, they are due to the variation in the Coriolis effect with latitude. The waves were first identified in the Earth's atmosphere in 1939 by Carl-Gustaf Arvid Rossby who went on to explain their motion.

One can identify a Rossby wave in that its phase velocity (that of the wave crests) always has a westward component. However, the wave's group velocity (associated with the energy flux) can be in any direction. In general, shorter waves have an eastward group velocity and long waves a westward group velocity.

The terms "barotropic" and "baroclinic" Rossby waves are used to distinguish their vertical structure:
  • 1) Barotropic Rossby waves do not vary in the vertical, and have the fastest propagation speeds.
    2) The baroclinic wave modes are slower, with speeds of only a few centimetres per second or less.
Most work on Rossby waves has been done on those in Earth's atmosphere. Rossby waves in the Earth's atmosphere are easy to observe as (usually 4-6) large-scale meanders of the jet stream. When these deviations become very pronounced, they detach the masses of cold, or warm, air that become cyclones and anticyclones and are responsible for day-to-day weather patterns at mid-latitudes. Rossby waves may be partly responsible for the fact that eastern continental edges, such as the Northeast United States and Eastern Canada, are colder than Europe at the same latitudes.>>

Re: APOD: Saturns Hexagon and Rings (2013 Feb 20)

by ChrisA » Wed Feb 20, 2013 3:40 pm

Indigo_Sunrise wrote:Very intriguing image!
One question: why does the link in this sentence (from the description; emphasis added):
If Saturn's South Pole wasn't strange enough with its rotating vortex,
take the user to an APOD that features Saturn's North Pole? Or is the link just an extremely close up view of the hexagon? :?
Yeah, this confused me, too. To be clear, Saturn has vortices at both poles. But AFAIK, only the North Pole has the hexagon. APOD just mislabeled their link to the 121204 entry (which was showing the vortex at the North Pole, not the South Pole).

Re: APOD: Saturns Hexagon and Rings (2013 Feb 20)

by Chris Peterson » Wed Feb 20, 2013 3:28 pm

rstevenson wrote:It seems complex systems, given the right conditions, naturally create geometric shapes, if not always stable ones.
It is worth noting that outside of carefully contrived setups, no complex system (which, in fact, includes systems that might seem incredibly simple to us) are stable. It's always a question of how long some sort of metastability can be maintained.

Re: APOD: Saturns Hexagon and Rings (2013 Feb 20)

by rstevenson » Wed Feb 20, 2013 3:10 pm

Just a few days ago I watched a recent episode of PBS's excellent Nova program, Earth From Space. Part way through it, in a section about weather systems around Antarctica, they showed a time-lapse video of low-pressure systems whirling around the continent over the space of motnhs. A sometimes hexagonal pattern appeared in a kind of pulsating way, not always there, not always hexagonal, but definitely a pattern. It seems complex systems, given the right conditions, naturally create geometric shapes, if not always stable ones.

Rob

Re: APOD: Saturns Hexagon and Rings (2013 Feb 20)

by MargaritaMc » Wed Feb 20, 2013 1:22 pm

walfy wrote:I'm surprised the APOD writers didn't even know that very excellent science was done in trying to figure out this strange structure. Here's your answer: http://www.planetary.org/blogs/emily-la ... /2471.html
This is from the link that walfy posted
Image
image courtesy of Ana Aguiar
Creating Saturn's hexagon in the laboratory

This is a top-down view of a laboratory tank in an experiment designed to reproduce the wind conditions near Saturn's north pole. The whole cylindrical tank is 60 centimeters wide. Its lid and base are split into two concentric sections, with the inner circle being 30 centimeters in diameter. The inner and outer circles are rotated at different rates, which sets up an instability at their boundary, producing a standing wave; the number of waves it takes to encircle the "pole" depends on various experimental parameters, including the rotation speed. In this particular case, the wavenumber is 6, producing a hexagon. Dye has been injected into the tank to make the form of the turbulent flow visible. Eddies are produced outside the wave.
As has previously been noted, the whole blog post is extremely worth studying.

Margarita

Re: APOD: Saturns Hexagon and Rings (2013 Feb 20)

by MargaritaMc » Wed Feb 20, 2013 1:02 pm

delgado wrote:I have seen this beautiful image of the Saturn hexagon. In the explanation it is said that the jovian plane eclipses the Saturn rings. I think his a mistake: jovian planet is Jupiter, isn't it? Can 'jovian' be used also for Saturn? Thanks
The quick answer is, "Yes."

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gas_giant
A gas giant (sometimes also known as a jovian planet after the planet Jupiter, or giant planet) is a large planet that is not primarily composed of rock or other solid matter.
Margarita

Top